Opens in a new tab

Rekey or replace: how to decide for your home

A working lock does not always need replacing. Learn what rekeying changes, when new hardware is worth the cost and what a locksmith checks first.

Keep good hardware, replace worn locks

If the lock operates smoothly and the hardware is in good condition, rekeying gives you control of the keys without buying another lock. If the cylinder, bolt or latch is worn, damaged or corroded, changing the key will not correct the problem. The condition of the hardware decides which work makes sense.

A Cairn Lock & Key locksmith inspects a brass lock cylinder at the workshop bench

What changes when a lock is rekeyed

Rekeying changes the pins inside a lock cylinder so a new key operates it and the old keys no longer work. The lock body, handle, deadbolt and finish stay on the door. It is a practical choice when you want to change who holds a working key without changing hardware that still does its job.

Consider a house with three exterior doors. If the locks are in good condition, a locksmith can inspect their cylinders, determine which can be rekeyed and supply new keys. Compatible keyways may also allow several doors to work with one key. Different keyways cannot necessarily be combined.

At Cairn Lock & Key, rekeying is $22 per cylinder, plus the separate $39 service call fee. The technician confirms the work and gives you a written price after inspecting the locks. Not every lock accepts rekeying.

Signs that replacement makes more sense

A new key cannot repair a worn cylinder or make a low-grade deadbolt stronger. If the key catches, the bolt does not move smoothly or the lock has visible damage, the technician needs to find the cause before recommending rekeying.

Replacement is worth considering when you find:

  • A cylinder with worn or damaged internal parts.
  • Corrosion that affects the lock’s operation.
  • Hardware that no longer latches or locks correctly.
  • A basic lock you want to upgrade to a higher grade.
  • A handle or deadbolt you want in another style or finish.
  • A mechanical lock you want to replace with a smart lock.

Not every difficult door needs a new lock. In Las Vegas, heat can expand metal doors and frames until a bolt binds against its strike. An alignment problem may need hardware adjustment rather than cylinder replacement.

Understand the grade before upgrading

Locks carry ANSI/BHMA grades that distinguish different levels of hardware performance. Grade 1 is the highest of the three grades and is used for commercial and heavy residential applications. Grade 2 serves residential and light commercial doors. Grade 3 is basic residential hardware.

Moving to a higher grade means selecting different hardware, not changing the pins in the lock you have. The door and frame matter too. A residential deadbolt should extend a full 1 inch into the frame, with a reinforced strike plate secured by 3 inch screws reaching the wall stud.

A locksmith can check whether the existing door preparation accepts the replacement hardware. Choosing a grade without inspecting the door may leave an installation problem unresolved.

Let the condition of the door decide

Before spending money on replacement, have each exterior door checked with the door both open and closed. The technician looks at the cylinder, bolt, latch, strike and alignment. A lock that turns freely with the door open but binds when closed may point to the door or frame rather than the cylinder.

Sun-facing doors in the Las Vegas valley take considerable heat. Dust also collects in keyways, particularly on exterior gates. Those conditions can affect how hardware operates over time.

After inspection, you may find that some locks need rekeying, others need adjustment and one needs replacement. There is no reason to treat every door the same when their conditions differ.

Cairn provides a written price before starting. Replacement hardware is priced separately, and no drilling or replacement proceeds without approval. When the work is finished, the technician tests the new keys and checks that the door latches and locks correctly.

Questions before changing your locks

These details help you plan the work and understand what happens after a locksmith has checked the doors.

Call (702) 000-0000All questions
Can I keep my existing keys for some doors and change the others?

Yes. You can choose which cylinders are rekeyed and which remain unchanged. The technician will identify the new keys and test each lock with you so you can tell them apart.

Does a new deadbolt come with a workmanship warranty?

Cairn provides a 12-month workmanship warranty on its installation labor. Hardware supplied by Cairn carries the manufacturer’s warranty, which varies by product.

Can a locksmith install a lock I purchased myself?

Yes. Cairn installs customer-supplied residential locks, including compatible smart locks. The 12-month workmanship warranty covers labor only. The hardware remains under its manufacturer’s warranty, which the customer handles.

More guidance for your home's locks

Make the right change to your locks

Cairn serves the Las Vegas valley. Call for an urgent lock problem, or use the request form to arrange an inspection or planned lock work.